As we continue the conversation about engaging potential clients who are already working with an advisor, let’s take a look at three approaches not to take.
1. Criticizing the existing advisor
It may be tempting to argue that a market-focused advisor is only interested in keeping assets under management or that investment diversification cannot protect a client from every market decline. But broad accusations can quickly weaken trust.
Prospects may have known their current advisor for years. If they feel pressured to defend that person, the conversation stops being about their retirement needs.
Better approach:
Respect the existing relationship and identify where a protection focused specialist may add a different perspective.
2. Claiming to provide the exact same service
Equating an annuity or insurance practice with a market-based investment practice can be equally unhelpful. If the services are framed as identical, the prospect has little reason to add another relationship.
It also blurs the purpose of the conversation. A prospect may need to understand how a fixed indexed annuity, life insurance, long-term care solution, final expense plan, disability coverage, trust, or income strategy fits alongside their existing investments.
Better approach:
Clearly explain the distinct role you can play in their overall plan.
3. Leading with product features before understanding the case
Strong rates and index options can attract attention, but a product discussion should follow a clear understanding of the client’s goals, liquidity needs, timeline, and suitability considerations.
A product may be attractive because it offers a high first-year fixed rate, index-linked crediting choices, or a specific withdrawal provision. None of those features alone determines whether it belongs in a particular plan.
Better approach:
Start with planning needs, then connect product features to the needs the prospect has identified.
The most effective way to handle the existing advisor objection is to stop treating it as a competition. Respect the relationship already in place, then help the prospect consider the full range of retirement issues that may deserve attention.
When a fixed indexed annuity is appropriate, explain it in the same context: not as a standalone rate story, but as a strategy with specific benefits, limits, crediting options, withdrawal rules, and suitability requirements. That combination of respectful positioning and thorough planning creates a stronger foundation for both client trust and the advisor relationship.
Scale Your Practice Without the Administrative Burden
Do you find this information helpful? TWH Agency is a top IMO for insurance agents and financial advisors who want to grow more profitably. From expert marketing and case design support for financial advisors and insurance agents to handling all of the red tape, paperwork, and day-to-day operational support, our dedicated concierge insurance IMO team handles the complexities so you can focus on building client relationships and close new business. With TWH Agency as your annuity and life insurance marketing organization, you gain streamlined operations, customized product solutions, and the support you need to grow your practice with confidence. Contact us to learn more about our advisor support platform, annuity case design help, how we provide insurance agent and financial advisor marketing ideas tailored to your specific practice, and more. We look forward to partnering with you!